FMI: 72% of Grocery Shoppers Call Their Store's Loyalty Program Essential to Staying on Budget, but Membership Falls to 58% Among Households Earning Under $35,000
FMI's U.S. Grocery Shopper Trends 2026: Holidays report, released November 12, finds 71% of shoppers have joined their primary store's loyalty program where one exists and 72% call it essential to saving money. Member-only holiday discounts were shoppers' top request for making Thanksgiving easier, at 36%.
FMI, the food industry association, released its U.S. Grocery Shopper Trends 2026: Holidays report on November 12, Mass Market Retailers reported. The survey, conducted with The Hartman Group among 1,467 U.S. grocery shoppers between September 21 and 28, found 45% are extremely or very concerned about rising holiday food prices, up 8 points from fall 2025, while average weekly grocery spending held at $172.
Loyalty programs feature heavily in how shoppers say they are coping. Where a program is offered, 71% have joined at their primary store, and 72% strongly or somewhat agree it is essential to saving money and staying within budget. Among members, 95% find the program at least somewhat valuable and 74% rate it extremely or highly valuable. Asked how grocers could make Thanksgiving preparation easier, shoppers put holiday discounts for loyalty members first at 36%, ahead of special meal displays at 29%. Asked to choose, 47% prefer general savings and 30% personalized offers.
The report also shows who is missing. Membership stands at 58% among shoppers earning under $35,000, against 78% for those earning $150,000 or more. Among non-members, 18% say they did not know the program existed and 28% give no particular reason for not joining. Where the primary store has no program, 68% are extremely or very interested in one. FMI president and CEO Leslie G. Sarasin said loyalty programs "are delivering exactly what shoppers need right now." The Shelby Report carried the same findings on November 13.
Why it matters for loyalty teams
Read the 72% with its base in mind. It counts shoppers who somewhat agree, it covers only stores that already run a program, and it comes from the grocers' own trade association. It measures how members feel about discounts they receive, and says nothing about whether those discounts change where or how much they buy.
The more useful figure is the income gap. The households most squeezed by food prices are 20 points less likely to be enrolled, and nearly one in five non-members did not know a program existed. Putting the lowest holiday price behind membership therefore steers the discount toward better-off shoppers, and an app-only or email-gated sign-up widens that gap. A grocer that makes member pricing its main price message is accepting that trade.
For a regional grocer or any high-frequency retailer, the affordable version is plain. General savings beat personalized offers 47 to 30, so a phone number at the till and a short list of member-priced seasonal items does most of the work without an offer engine. The cost is margin given away on baskets that would have come anyway, so judge the result on basket size and trip frequency, not sign-ups. Low-frequency retailers should not assume any of this carries over.
Analysis by LoyaltyWire Editorial.